
Joel Kotkin, a senior fellow at the New America Foundation in Irvine, asserts that Los Angeles should continue to be a city of primarily single family homes and that Mayor Villaraigosa’s attempt to create denser residential development along public transport routes is wrong.
In a LA Times opinion piece, he writes, “But what sets L.A. apart from other great cities — and what makes it so attractive — has traditionally been exactly the opposite: its pattern of dispersion and its strong attachment to the single-family home. Assault that basic form and you will turn L.A. not into Paris but something more like an unruly, congested, dense Third World city. A Tehran, if you will, or a Mexico City.”
Isn’t most of LA already like Mexico City or Tehran? You can’t walk down Westwood Boulevard or stop into a Tarz-ino Starbucks without hearing Farsi… and Mexico City has already transplanted itself here. Denser building hasn’t done anything that immigration hasn’t done already.
He also claims: “Virtually everywhere in the advanced industrial world — from Tokyo to Toronto and Paris to Buenos Aires — the bulk of metropolitan job and population growth is occurring in places that look more like Manhattan Beach than Manhattan. Meanwhile, many celebrated older cities, including Chicago, Boston, San Francisco, Paris, Frankfurt, Hamburg and Tokyo, are losing population.” Rather than comparing population statistics, he might ask about the civic health of the inhabitants. Do Tokyo, Hamburg, Paris and Frankfurt have nightly drive-by shootings, uninsured and illiterate residents and more guns than people?
He also asks: “Do we really want to be like Chicago, New York or San Francisco? These are all expensive cities with economies that have been creating fewer jobs and opportunities than Los Angeles. They also have fewer children per capita.” Yes, yes, yes! I want to live in a city with less children, because Mexico City , Tehran and any other underdeveloped city has a higher percentage of young people because poorer people have more children. New York, San Francisco and Chicago are attracting young professionals who have invigorated once decrepit industrial neighborhoods and revitalized older ethnic ones. Where in Los Angeles do you find a neighborhood like Soho in New York or Pacific Heights in San Francisco?
As far as building a denser city, Mr. Kotkin should look at the unplanned and car centered, gilded skyscrapers along Wilshire Boulevard in Westwood. Here is development gone awry without any regard for the pedestrian or public transportation. It is a freeway of speeding SUV’s amidst a cacophony of architectural mediocrity and pretentious grandiosity. There are no parks, stores or benches—only a speedway of steel bouncing off marble facades.
Density is here to stay, the single family house is for multi-millionaires. We have to find a way to house LA, and Mayor Villaraigosa is right to explore new options and ways of building.
You must be logged in to post a comment.