Caltrans photo: OmarOmar
This blog could be an endless screed against Los Angeles and Van Nuys in particular, and sometimes it is. Our problems seem endless, and the built environment is demoralizing. We live in the midst of a paradise of climate, that is constructed in a way that keeps us isolated in our cars, stuck in traffic, under the haze, longing to get outside for fresh air and human interaction.
Once again, I visited the website Carfree and looked at photos of European cities where pedestrians are king, and many people get around on their bicycles. There are also images of plazas, and those wonderful meandering streets with narrow walkways, that give a city a sense of mystery and delight. Where Venice has the Piazza San Marco, Los Angeles must make due with Pershing Square, or better yet, the hellish concrete nonscape of Sherman Way in the San Fernando Valley.
We keep hearing about the exciting changes that are coming to Los Angeles, but on a recent visit downtown I had the horrendous experience of seeing Thom Mayne’s Caltrans building up close: a black-glass, violently anti-social, concrete skycraper that encapsulates every negative characteristic of LA. There were no windows or doors on the sidewalk: only a blind and indifferent blankness on all four sides. Amusing in its oddness, conceptually clever, but deadly in its incarnation. Imagine an entire city constructed by Mr. Mayne, his way: architectural nihilism. Hiroshima was a tragedy, not a blueprint.
We progressives are left to imagine the city of the future only in revitalizing those sections of Los Angeles that were built in the 1920’s. I love Silver Lake and Echo Park, because here is where the pedestrians climb staircases, the shops and stores are unique, built into hills and curving streets, and one can walk anywhere.
But the vast resources of Nokia, Walt Disney, Eli Broad, and Staples, and yes, Caltrans are intent on erecting enormous ego and profit driven dreck that is praised only because the media smells dollars the way a mosquito smells blood. The LA car show, a dinosaur of design, is an example of how global warming can never compete with the sexualized come-ons of this retrograde event. Just what LA needs: more cars. They might as well have a downtown convention to recruit new gang members.
In Los Angeles, we have noble ideas, but even the idea of extending the subway to the sea, for a paltry extra $250 million (Tom Cruise’s monthly salary?) is something that must be fought (for/against) as if it were a frivolous toy, instead of a transportation necessity.
So we continue to build new lofts downtown, and tear down perfectly good neighborhoods in Studio City for condos, while much of the rest of the lower rent city languishes.
I want to live in a city where I can ride a train anywhere from Santa Clarita to Palm Springs, from Camarillo to Anaheim. I want to live in a city where Van Nuys is lined with big oak trees along Van Nuys Boulevard, and billboards and wooden power lines are gone. I want to take a breath of air that doesn’t stink of diesel exhaust, or hops from the Budweiser plant, or Woodley Park sewage, or smell of the Vietnamese restaurant down the street.
I know it’s a lot to ask, and for now it seems beyond our capacity to build, so I will be dreaming of bicycles instead.





Agree on all counts, as I work right by the Van Nuys airport. But I’m a bit disappointed you’d include Vietnamese cuisine alongside factory belches and sewage odours. I love the ethnic cuisine smells of LA…that I would never wish would disappear.
LikeLike
Agreed. And Van Nuys and much of the older parts of the valley was built out for working and then middle class folks who worked primarily for the former big factories in the Valley — Aerospace and Automobile. And when they were built, they were still serviced by light rail running down the main boulevards.
LikeLike
Sorry, you’ll have to explain the connection between “I Love Lucy” and the built environment of Los Angeles. I assumed that most of our uglier apartments were influenced by the “I Dream of Jeannie” era.
LikeLike
The subway to the sea will cost only $250 million?! I wish! I believe an extra digit was omitted–assuming the owner of this blog wasn’t trying to be facetious. $2.5 billion sounds closer to the estimate.
Sadly, Los Angeles was like the city you described back in the 40s.
However, you fail to note that some of the worst communities and streets in Los Angeles were built back then. The older houses and strip commercial-retail buildings of Van Nuys, as one example, ugly in a backwater, blue-collar sort of way, are a sad legacy of the era when Lucy and Ricky Ricardo were entertaining millions each week on TV. And the electricity that powered those early TVs, and the telephones people used to talk to one another about the latest antics of the crazy redhead, were routinely connected to lines draped all over, and fully visible throughout, the neighborhoods of Los Angeles.
If such areas had instead been built with greater care, so that their potential charm and attractiveness hadn’t been smothered in the process, they’d have been less vulnerable to the decline they’re now trapped in, or they at least could be turned around or revived today with less difficulty.
LikeLike
Sadly, Los Angeles was like the city you described back in the 40s. Then the car companies, tire companies and oil companies (and, for that matter, politicians) conspired to dismantle the streetcars and were found guilty of that by the US Supreme Court, but what was done was done.
Only recently have we seen the folly of our ways. The current state of gridlock should be seen as a city emergency and the same resources that were spent on rebuilding the freeways after the Northridge quake should go into extending the purple line to the beach, extending the expo line and adding that pink line.
Moreover, extend the Gold line to Ontario, make the green line hit LAX, add more bus lines, and if the government can’t do it, then make it private.
Better public transit in LA is coming, it is a necessity and the more people speak up, the more likely it will happen sooner than later.
LikeLike
well said.
LikeLike